Top 10 Pizza Places in New York City
New York City is renowned for its iconic pizza, with a multitude of pizzerias offering a variety of styles and flavors. Among the top ten pizza places, visitors and locals alike can find everything from classic New York-style slices to artisanal pies brimming with gourmet toppings. Each establishment has its own unique charm and history, making the pizza experience in the city truly unforgettable.
Advertisement
Among the standout pizzerias, Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn is often hailed as a must-visit, famous for its hand-crafted pies made by the legendary Dom DeMarco. Joe's Pizza in Greenwich Village is another iconic spot, known for its quintessential New York slices that locals have cherished for decades. For those seeking a unique twist, Artichoke Basille's Pizza offers innovative toppings, including their signature artichoke and spinach slice. Additionally, Lucali, with its cozy atmosphere and brick-oven pizzas, has garnered a loyal following. Other noteworthy mentions include L&B Spumoni Gardens, known for its Sicilian-style pizza, and Prince Street Pizza, celebrated for its pepperoni slices. Each of these establishments showcases the diverse and rich pizza culture of NYC, making it a delicious adventure for any pizza lover.
View AllDi Fara Pizza - Legendary Brooklyn pizzeria known for handmade, authentic pizzas.
View AllLucali - Famous for wood-fired pies and cozy atmosphere.
View AllJoe's Pizza - Iconic slice, classic New York-style, casual atmosphere.
View AllL'Industrie Pizzeria - Artisanal pizzas with unique toppings and vibrant atmosphere.
View AllPrince Street Pizza - Famous for its pepperoni slices and crispy crust.
View AllPatsy's Pizzeria - Iconic pizzeria known for classic, thin-crust New York pizza.
View AllRoberta's - Trendy, artisanal pizzas with unique toppings and vibrant atmosphere.
View AllJohn's of Bleecker Street - Famous for coal-fired pies and classic New York atmosphere.
View AllMotorino - Authentic Neapolitan pizza with a cozy atmosphere.
View AllTotonno's - Classic pizzeria known for coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas.
Top 10 Pizza Places in New York City
1.
Di Fara Pizza
Di Fara Pizza, located in Brooklyn, New York, is a legendary eatery celebrated for its authentic, handcrafted pizza. Founded in 1965 by Domenico DeMarco, this family-run pizzeria combines traditional Italian techniques with the finest ingredients, including imported San Marzano tomatoes and hand-grated cheese. Each pizza is meticulously prepared by DeMarco himself, ensuring an unparalleled flavor that has garnered a devoted following. With its warm, inviting atmosphere and dedication to quality, Di Fara Pizza stands out as a quintessential destination for pizza lovers seeking an authentic Italian experience beyond Italy.
Pros
Authentic New York-style pizza- high-quality ingredients
- skilled craftsmanship
- iconic family-run establishment
- rich history and tradition.
Cons
Long wait times for a table- High prices compared to other pizzerias
- Limited seating capacity
- Inconsistent service quality
- No delivery options available.
2.
Lucali
Lucali, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, is a must-visit for pizza aficionados. Renowned for its artisanal approach, this cozy pizzeria offers a menu that showcases hand-stretched, brick oven pizzas made from high-quality ingredients. The ambiance is warm and inviting, with candlelit tables adding to its charm. The signature pie, featuring a perfectly charred crust and a harmonious blend of fresh toppings, is a crowd favorite. Lucali's commitment to excellence and its intimate setting make it a standout destination in New York City's vibrant pizza scene. Reservations are highly recommended due to its popularity.
Pros
- Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza
- cozy and intimate atmosphere
- fresh high-quality ingredients
- skilled and passionate staff
- popular with locals and tourists.
Cons
- Long wait times
- limited seating
- higher prices than average
- no reservations
- inconsistent service.
3.
Joe's Pizza
Joe's Pizza, a quintessential New York City pizzeria, has been serving up classic slices since 1975. Located in Greenwich Village, this iconic establishment is renowned for its thin-crust, foldable pizza topped with a perfect blend of tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. The no-frills atmosphere draws locals and tourists alike, who savor the authentic taste of NYC pizza. Open late and always bustling, Joe's has become a beloved staple in the city's culinary landscape, embodying the spirit of New York with each delicious slice.
Pros
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Generous toppings
- Affordable prices
- Cozy atmosphere
- Quick service
Cons
- Limited seating available
- higher prices compared to competitors
- inconsistent service during peak hours
- not enough vegetarian options
- long wait times.
4.
L'Industrie Pizzeria
L'Industrie Pizzeria, nestled in Brooklyn’s Williamsburg neighborhood, is celebrated for its artisanal approach to pizza. This trendy spot offers a menu that showcases classic Neapolitan-style pies, featuring a perfectly charred crust and high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. The vibrant atmosphere, complemented by a casual yet stylish interior, attracts both locals and visitors alike. Their standout offerings include the margherita and the pepperoni pies, each crafted with precision and passion. With a commitment to excellence, L'Industrie Pizzeria has earned its place among New York City's top pizza destinations.
Pros
- Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza
- creative topping combinations
- cozy and inviting atmosphere
- friendly and attentive staff
- reasonable prices for quality.
Cons
- Limited seating capacity
- higher prices than competitors
- longer wait times during peak hours
- menu may lack variety
- parking can be challenging.
5.
Prince Street Pizza
Prince Street Pizza, located in Manhattan's Nolita neighborhood, is renowned for its iconic pepperoni slices and vibrant atmosphere. This beloved pizzeria has gained a cult following for its thick, square-shaped Sicilian-style slices, characterized by a crispy crust and generous toppings. The standout pepperoni, which curls up and crisps to perfection, adds a delightful flavor to every bite. With its bustling exterior and cozy interior, Prince Street Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking a quintessential New York slice experience. The combination of quality ingredients and passionate craftsmanship makes it a top contender in NYC's competitive pizza scene.
Pros
- Iconic pepperoni slices
- crispy crust
- vibrant atmosphere
- generous toppings
- quick service.
Cons
- Long wait times during peak hours
- limited seating space
- inconsistent service quality
- higher prices compared to competitors
- can be overly greasy.
6.
Patsy's Pizzeria
Patsy's Pizzeria, a legendary establishment in New York City, has been serving up delicious, authentic coal-fired pizza since 1933. Located in East Harlem, this family-owned pizzeria is renowned for its thin, crispy crust and high-quality ingredients, including fresh mozzarella and flavorful tomato sauce. The warm, inviting atmosphere and vintage decor add to its charm, making it a favorite among locals and tourists alike. With a commitment to traditional recipes and superb flavor, Patsy's remains a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking a true New York experience.
Pros
- Authentic coal-fired pizza
- Rich mozzarella and fresh toppings
- Cozy and inviting atmosphere
- Friendly and attentive staff
- Long-standing local favorite
Cons
- Long wait times during peak hours
- limited seating available
- higher prices compared to competitors
- inconsistent service quality
- parking can be difficult.
7.
Roberta's
Roberta's is a renowned pizzeria located in Bushwick, Brooklyn, celebrated for its artisanal approach to pizza. Established in 2008, the restaurant quickly gained fame for its wood-fired pies, using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and house-made dough. The menu features a variety of creative toppings, with standout options like the "Bee Sting," topped with spicy honey. Beyond pizza, Roberta's offers a vibrant atmosphere, featuring a cozy dining space and an outdoor garden. Its commitment to quality and innovative flavors has solidified its status as one of New York City's top pizza destinations.
Pros
- Unique wood-fired pizzas
- vibrant atmosphere
- locally sourced ingredients
- creative toppings
- renowned for its artisanal approach.
Cons
- Limited seating
- longer wait times
- higher prices
- inconsistent service
- location can be inconvenient.
8.
John's of Bleecker Street
John's of Bleecker Street, a legendary pizzeria in Greenwich Village, has been serving up delicious, coal-fired pizzas since 1929. Known for its classic New York-style thin crust, the pizzeria boasts a vibrant, no-frills atmosphere that attracts locals and tourists alike. With a menu featuring a variety of toppings and their signature Margherita pizza, John's prioritizes fresh ingredients and traditional preparation methods. The bustling dining room, adorned with vintage memorabilia, adds to the charm, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers exploring the culinary landscape of New York City.
Pros
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- rich flavor and fresh ingredients
- iconic Greenwich Village location
- casual and inviting atmosphere
- long-standing family tradition.
Cons
- Long wait times
- limited seating
- inconsistent service
- higher prices
- not as many topping options.
9.
Motorino
Motorino is a beloved pizzeria in New York City, renowned for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. Established by chef Mathieu Palombino, the restaurant emphasizes high-quality ingredients, with a wood-fired oven that creates perfectly charred, chewy crusts. The menu features a variety of classic and inventive toppings, including the popular Margherita and the unique Brussels Sprouts pizza. With its warm, inviting atmosphere and commitment to traditional techniques, Motorino has earned a loyal following among locals and visitors alike, making it a standout in NYC's vibrant pizza scene.
Pros
- Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza
- high-quality fresh ingredients
- cozy and inviting atmosphere
- friendly and knowledgeable staff
- great variety of toppings.
Cons
- Limited seating capacity
- higher prices than competitors
- inconsistent service quality
- location may be inconvenient for some
- long wait times during peak hours.
10.
Totonno's
Totonno's, located in Coney Island, is a legendary pizzeria renowned for its classic New York-style pizza. Established in 1924, it boasts a rich history and a time-honored recipe that features a perfectly charred, thin crust topped with high-quality tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. The pizzeria’s traditional coal-fired oven imparts a unique smoky flavor, making each pie a beloved favorite among locals and visitors alike. With its no-frills ambiance and commitment to authentic Italian flavors, Totonno's remains a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts in New York City.
Pros
- Authentic coal-fired pizzas
- flavorful and fresh ingredients
- rich family history
- iconic crispy crust
- classic New York atmosphere.
Cons
- Limited menu options
- long wait times
- inconsistent service
- cash-only policy
- parking challenges.
Similar Topic You Might Be Interested In
- Top 10 Authentic Italian Restaurants Outside Italy
- Top 10 Vegan-Friendly Restaurants in Major Cities
- Top 10 Korean BBQ Spots for Grill Lovers
- Top 10 French Bistros for Traditional Cuisine
- Top 10 Mediterranean Restaurants With Fresh Ingredients
- Top 10 Mexican Taquerias With Homemade Tortillas
- Top 10 Greek Tavernas Known for Seafood
- Top 10 Indian Restaurants Serving Traditional Thali
- Top 10 Japanese Sushi Spots for True Purists
- Top 10 Middle Eastern Restaurants With a Modern Twist